Below is a summary of the full article. Click here for the full version or go back to NUFC Live
Imagine the scenario - United are level with Sheffield United on Thursday night when they are awarded a penalty with just minutes to go.
He's never been on penalty duty in his club career - but did score an incredible backheel penalty in training with Holland which you can watch above.
Granted, a Newcastle penalty is about as common as rocking horse manure, but with Allan Saint-Maximin flying at defences at full speed, it wouldn't be a huge surprise to see United given a chance from 12 yards.
Some say the main striker should always be on penalty duty, while others prefer someone with a cool head.
Vote for any one of the seven candidates in our poll above to cast your vote.
Hayden has never taken a penalty in his club career and, along with Shelvey, missed against Leicester earlier this season.
Few would bet against either Sean or Matty Longstaff from shirking the responsibility from 12 yards, but there is a lack of penalty experience among the remainder of the squad.